4. Comparing Typefaces
The following 10 typefaces represents 500 years of type
design. They are still considered successful expressions
of how we think, how we read and write, how we
print.
|
|
Fig 8.1, Typefaces
|
Variety in x-height, in line weight, in relative stroke
widths and in feeling. Feelings of these typefaces connote specific use and
expression.
Examining typefaces tells us how we feel about specific
typefaces. It tells us what we bring to the discussion of
appropriateness in type choices.
Range of attitudes; some whimsical, some stately, some
mechanical, some calligraphic, some harmonious and some
awkward.
|
|
Fig 8.2, Comparing Typefaces
|
Lecture 3 - Text (Part 1/2)
1. Tracking: Kerning and Letterspacing
Kerning: the automatic adjustment of space between
letters (often mistaken as 'letterspacing') // to lessen space
between letters
|
|
Fig 9.1, Kerning
|
Letterspacing: to add space between the letters
Tracking: addition and removal of space in a word or
sentence
|
|
Fig 9.2, Normal tracking, Tight tracking, Loose tracking
|
Adjust sizing (command + shift + >/< key OR command +
shift + option)
When to kern (lesser space) (option + left arrow key) or
letterspace (option + right arrow key)
eg. for headlines, for titles, when the entire word is in
uppercase
Uppercase letterforms are drawn to be able to stand alone,
lowercase letterforms require the counterform created
between letters to maintain the line of reading (so kerning
and letterspacing lowercase letters within text is a NO).
If we add letterspacing, it breaks the counterform, which
lessens the readability.
|
|
Fig 9.3, Counterform: black spaces in
between the white letterforms
|
2. Formatting Text (Alignments)
Designers tend to set type on several factors, personal
preference, prevailing culture and the need to express play
important roles. However, their first job is to provide clear,
appropriate presentation of the author's message.
Flush left: writing from left to right, closely
mirroring the asymmetrical exp of handwriting. Each word
starts at the same point but ends wherever the last word on
the line ends (ragged right). Spaces between words are
consistent, allowing the type to create an even grey value.
|
|
Fig 10.1, Flush left
|
Centered: symmetry upon the text, equal value and
weight to both ends of any line (ragged right and left).
Transformed fields of text into shapes, adding pictorial
quality to a material that is non-pictorial in nature. Creates
a strong shape on a page, important to amend line breaks so
the text does not appear too jagged.
|
|
Fig 10.2, Centered
|
Flush right: places emphasis on the end of a line as
opposed to its start (ragged left). Difficult to read in large
pieces of text. Useful in situations (like captions) where the
relationship between text and image might be ambiguous w/o a
strong orientation to the right.
|
|
Fig 10.3, Flush right
|
Justified: imposes a symmetrical shape on the text.
Achieved by expanding or reducing spaces between words, and
sometimes, between letters. Resulting openness of lines can
produce 'rivers' of white spaces running vertically thru the
text. Careful attention to line breaks and hyphenation is
needed to amend this problem whenever possible.
Reflection of certain types of mentality cuz it gives a sense
of order.
|
|
Fig 10.4, Justified
|
3. Texture
|
|
Fig 11.1, Anatomy of a Typeface
|
x-height: height between the baseline and the median line
ascender: space above the x-height
descender: space below the x-height
when the ascender & descender is smaller in comparison to
the x-height (it normally is), there's more readability.
(none of the typefaces below are designed for on screen
reading purposes)
|
|
Fig 11.2 10 point size / 13.5 leading / typeface (Adobe
Casion/Baskerville)
|
Baskerville has a slightly larger x-height & tends to be
generally readable
|
|
Fig 11.3, 10 point size / 13.5 leading / typeface
(Bembo/Adobe Garamond Pro)
|
Garamond has a larger ascender and descender and has a thicker
stroke, making it more readable.
Bembo has a little bit more contrast, reducing its application
as a typeface at this point size and for on screen reading
purposes.
|
|
Fig 11.4, 10 point size / 13.5 leading / typeface (Bauer
Bodoni/Adobe Jenson Pro)
|
Bodoni has a high contrast level, reducing the
readability/legibility of some of its strokes.
Jenson Pro has a thicker stroke, the colour is a lot more
stronger which makes it more readable at this point size and
on screen purposes
|
|
Fig 11.5, Same point size (10), leading size (13.5) ,
different typefaces and different grey values
|
(half close your eyes to see the grey value)
(own judgement)
It seems that Jenson Pro has the darkest colour, therefore
readable.
Bodoni has the lightest colour because of contrast issues
(thick and thin stokes, the thicker the strokes are, the thin
strokes seems to disappear)
|
|
Fig 11.6, Comparison of san serif typefaces
|
For screen reading purposes, these are more legible.
4. Leading and Line Length
The goal in setting text type is to allow for easy,
prolonged reading.
At the same time, as field of type should occupy the page
as much as a photograph does.
The following 3 things (decided one to another) determines
readability and legibility.
Type size: Text should be large enough to read
easily at arms length.
First thing to decide on when designing a text.
Leading: Text set too tightly encourages vertical
eye movement which lets the reader loose their place. Test
set too loosely creates striped patterns that distracts
the reader from the material at hand.
Decided on the vertical eye movement of the reader, or the
grey value, or the colour, after deciding on the type size
(large body of text generally requires 2~3.5 points more
than type size).
Line Length: Shorter lines requires less reading;
longer lines more. A good rule of thumb is to keep line
length between 55-65 characters. Too long or too short
impairs reading.
|
|
Fig 12.1, Bad leading
|
On the left, virtually no leading, colour is too dark.
On the right, too much leading, colour is too light.
|
|
Fig 12.2, Comparison of different leading size
|
~10/12 is probably the best. (but this is subjective)
5. Type Specimen Book
If the ultimate output of a particular text is to be
printed, we have to print it out to judge.
If it is is going to be on screen, we make a judgement on
screen (to see whether it looks good, is readable and
legible).
A type specimen book is a sheet or a book showing samples
of typefaces in various different sizes. Without printed
pages showing this, no one can make a reasonable choice of
type cuz choices can only be determined on screen.
A type specimen book (or ebook) is to provide an accurate
reference for type, type size, type leading, type line
length, etc.
|
|
Fig 13, Sample type specimen sheet
|
Lecture 4 - Text (Part 2/2)
6. Indicating Paragraphs
Pilcrow
(¶): previously, it was used to indicate paragraph
spacing // holdover in medieval manuscripts seldom
used today
|
|
Fig 14.1, Pilcrow indicating paragraph
|
Line Space (leading*): space between paragraphs. If the line space
(leading) is 12pt, then the paragraph space is 12pt.
Ensures cross-alignment across columns of text (2
columns of text in line w one another).
(*leading is 2~3.5 points larger than the type
size)
(we always press enter twice for paragraph space,
which is wrong)
There is a value for the paragraph space, ideally
paragraph space point size = leading point size (=
line space)
|
|
Fig 14.2, Line space vs Leading
|
leading - jelly
line of type - bread
line space - jelly + bread (descender of one
sentence to the descender of the next
sentence)
|
|
Fig 14.3, Line spacing indicating paragraph
|
Standard indentation: indent size = line spacing size OR point size of
your text
(too big point size indentation causes ragging on
the left esp when there are many short
paragraphs)
(best used when text is justified, if not there
will be ragging on both sides)
|
|
Fig 14.4, indentation indicating paragraph
|
Extended paragraphs: creates unusually wide columns of text. Generally
not used but there may be strong compositional or
functional reasons for choosing it
|
|
Fig 14.5, Extended paragraphs
|
7. Widows and Orphans
Must never occur in our design // must take care to
avoid these occurrences (esp w large amounts of
text)
Widow: a short line of type left alone at the end of a
column of a text
Orphan: a short line of type left alone at the start of a
new column
|
|
Fig 15, Widows and Orphans
|
Justified text v unforgiving towards these
Flush right and ragged left are somewhat more
forgiving
Widow solution- forced line break (shift + enter)
thru out ur para
OR changing kerning or letterspacing (highlight +
option + left arrow key) (but only by not more or
less than 3 times!)
Orphan solution- reducing length of the
column
8. Highlighting Text
(within a column of text)
Different ways of highlighting text:
- italics
- bold or medium
- change the typeface (might need to reduce point
size (by usually 0.5), etc cuz generally, san serif
typefaces seem to be larger)
|
|
Fig 16, Changing serif to san serif
|
- change colour (body text can only be changed
between black, cyan, magenta and yellow)
- placing a box around the text/field of colour
behind the text, maintaining the reading axis (or not,
depends on the individual)
- bullet list
(sometimes it is necessary to place certain
typographic elements outside the left margin of a
column text to maintain strong reading axis)
-
quotation marks (like bullets, can create a clear
indent, breaking the left reading axis)
|
|
Fig 17, Indented quote (top) vs extended quote
(bottom)
|
Prime ≠ Quotations!!
Prime indicates feet (single) and inches
(double)
|
|
Fig 18, Primes (top) vs Quotations (bottom)
|
9. Headline within Text
Subdivisions within text of a chapters.
A head indicates a clear break between the topics
within a section.
|
|
Fig 19.1, A heads
|
B head is subordinate to A heads. B head indicate
a new supporting argument or example for the topic at
hand. They should not interrupt the text as strongly
as A heads do.
|
|
Fig 19.2, B heads
|
C heads, tho not common, highlights specific facets
of material within B head text. They do not
materially interrupt the flow of reading.
|
|
Fig 19.3, C heads
|
Putting together a sequence of subheads =
hierarchy
|
|
Fig 19.4, A-B-C combination
|
10. Cross Alignment
Cross aligning headlines and captions with text
type reinforces the architectural sense of the
page—the structure—while articulating the
complimentary vertical rhythms.
|
|
Fig 20, Cross alignment between different
point sizes
|
Lecture 5 - Letters
1. Understanding Letterforms
The below uppercase letter form suggests symmetry, but is not. It has 2 different stroke weights of the Baskerville stroke form & each bracket connecting the serif to the stem has a unique arc (circles show the arcs).
 |
| Fig 21.1, Baskerville 'A' |
The below uppercase letter form may appear symmetrical, but the width. of the left slope is thinner than the right stroke.
 |
| Fig 21.2, Univers 'A' |
Both Baskerville and Univers demonstrate the meticulous care a type designer takes to create letterforms that are both internally harmonious and individually expressive.
The complexity of each individual letterform is neatly demonstrated by examining the lowercase 'a' of 2 seemingly similar sans-serif typefaces- Helvetica and Univers. A comparison of how the stems of the letterforms finish and how the bowls meet the stems quickly reveals the palpable difference in character between the 2.
 |
| Fig 22.1, Helvetica 'a' vs Universe 'a' |
 |
| Fig 22.2, Comparison |
2. Maintaining the x-height
x-height: size of the lowercase letterforms
The curved strokes, such as in 's', must rise above the median (or sink below the baseline) in order to appear to the same size as the vertical and horizontal strokes they adjoin.
 |
| Fig 23, Curved strokes exceeding median & baseline |
'o' usually looks smaller because it has lesser 'real estate' (lesser area touching the median and baseline). To compensate for that, an optical adjustment is necessary (by exceeding the median and baseline).
3. Form / Counterform
Counterform (or counter)- the space describes, and often contained, by the strokes of the form. When letters are joined to form words, the counterform includes the spaces between them.
How well counters are handled determines the readability of what's been set.
 |
| Fig 24, Form and Counterform |
 |
| Fig 25, Letters in close detail to understand form and counter |
4. Contrast
 |
| Fig 26, Contrast in letters |
Lecture 6 - Different Medium
In the past, typography was viewed as living only when it reached paper.
Today, typography not only exist on paper, but on a multitude of screens. Our exp of typography changes based on how the page is rendered, because typesetting happens in the browser.
1. Print Type vs Screen Type
Type for Print
Type was designed intended for reading from print long before we read from screen. It's the designer's job to ensure that the text is smooth, flowing, and pleasant to read.
Caslon, Garamond, Baskerville are the most common typefaces used for print because of their characteristic which are elegant and intellectual but also highly readable when set at small font sizes.
They are versatile, easy-to-digest classic typefaces, which has a neutrality and versatility that makes typesetting with it easy.
 |
| Fig 27, Typography (that has been used a lot) in novels |
 |
| Fig 28, Typography in print |
Type for Screen
Typefaces intended for use on the web are optimised and often modified to enhance readability and performance onscreen in a variety of digital environments.
Eg: taller x-height, reduced ascenders/descenders, wider letterforms, more open counters, heavier thin strokes and serifs, reduced stroke contract, modified curves and angles)
Another important adjustment (esp for typefaces intended for smaller sizes): open spacing.
These factors serve to improve character recognition and overall readability on screen including the web, e-books, e-readers, and mobile devices.
 |
| Fig 29, Typography on a website |
Hyperactive Link / Hyperlink: a word, phrase, or image you. can click to jump to a new document or section within the current document. Text hyperlinks are normally blue and underlines by default. An old and current way to navigate an online document.
Comments
Post a Comment